In this episode of Hiring to Firing, hosts Tracey Diamond and Emily Schifter use the Netflix hit America’s Sweethearts: Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders as a lens to examine best practices in providing effective employee feedback. Joined by Ann Hart, vice president of human resources at ampliFI Loyalty Solutions, they unpack what the show gets right — and wrong — about challenging performance discussions, from high-stakes cuts from the team to real-time coaching.

The discussion explores how to turn feedback into a tool for growth, how to leverage annual performance reviews and ongoing dialogue, and how to use performance improvement plans in good faith rather than as mere paper trails. Tune in for concrete strategies to help managers deliver clear, timely, and compassionate feedback that supports employees, strengthens culture, and reduces legal risk.

Transcript: Cuts, Choreography, and Coaching: What America’s Sweethearts Teach Us About Performance Management (PDF)


Troutman Pepper Locke’s Labor + Employment Practice Group provides comprehensive thought leadership through various channels. We regularly issue advisories that offer timely insights into the evolving employment law landscape, and maintain the HiringToFiring.Law Blog, a resource spotlighting best practices for employers. Our Hiring to Firing Podcast, hosted by Tracey Diamond and Emily Schifter, delves into pressing labor and employment law topics, drawing unique parallels from pop culture, hit shows, and movies.